Is It Possible to Repurpose a Research Question for Both a Thesis and a Dissertation?

When it comes to conducting research for a thesis and a dissertation, students often wonder if they can use the same research question. While this is possible, especially if the academic requirements align and the topic offers sufficient depth, there are nuances and considerations to keep in mind. In this article, we will explore the feasibility and implications of repurposing a research question for both projects, as well as offer guidance on how to approach this decision.

Repurposing a Research Question: A Feasible Approach?

It is indeed possible to use the same topic for both a thesis and a dissertation, depending on the academic requirements of your institution and specific guidelines for each project. In many cases, the two projects share similar purposes: both require original research, critical analysis, and the presentation of findings in a scholarly manner. Therefore, it is not uncommon for students to choose a topic that can be explored in-depth for both projects.

Understanding the Differences: Theses vs. Dissertations

While a thesis and a dissertation share some similarities, there are key differences that may influence your decision. The most important distinction is that a dissertation is typically required for a doctoral degree, while a thesis is usually associated with a master's degree. Additionally, the scope and depth of research may vary between the two projects. Dissertations often necessitate more extensive research and a broader contribution to the field.

Key Considerations Before Repurposing

Before deciding to use the same topic for both a thesis and a dissertation, it is crucial to carefully review the requirements and expectations for each project. You should also consider whether the topic has enough depth and breadth to sustain two separate research projects. Consulting with your academic advisors can provide valuable guidance and ensure that your approach meets the necessary standards.

Why Repurposing a Research Question Might Be Discouraged

While the temptation to carry over a research question from a thesis to a dissertation might be strong, there are nuanced considerations to keep in mind. In most cases, using the exact same research question for both projects is discouraged. Here’s why:

The Differences in Scope and Depth

Thesis: Aims to answer a focused question within a limited timeframe, showcasing your understanding of existing research and your ability to apply it to a specific problem. Dissertation: Represents a significant and original contribution to your field, demonstrating in-depth research, independent analysis, and the ability to break new ground.

Replicating the exact same question would imply that the research conducted for the thesis has already exhausted its potential, which is unlikely for a doctoral-level dissertation. Instead, the dissertation should build upon and extend the research initiated in the thesis.

Maintaining Originality and Contribution

A dissertation demands originality and a substantial advancement in knowledge compared to previous research. Replicating a thesis question risks redundancy and fails to showcase the expected level of independent research and critical thinking. The dissertation should represent a significant step forward, demonstrating your intellectual growth and independent research skills.

Developing Your Research Trajectory

Using the same research question limits your opportunity to explore new facets of your chosen topic and demonstrate a deeper understanding. Instead, the dissertation should build upon the knowledge and insights gained from your thesis, allowing you to delve into new areas and demonstrate a progression in your research.

Exceptions: When Repurposing May Be Appropriate

Despite the general discouragement, there are situations where repurposing a research question may be appropriate. Here are a few scenarios:

Refining the Research Question

Even if the original question was comprehensive, it may not have fully explored all aspects of the topic. If your thesis research identified significant unexplored avenues within the original question, you can refine it to become a more complex and dissertation-worthy inquiry.

Addressing Sub-Questions

Your thesis question might have contained sub-questions, one or more of which could be expanded and developed into the basis for your dissertation exploration. By doing so, you can build on your initial research and contribute new insights.

Important Factors to Consider

The decision to repurpose a research question depends on several factors:

University/program guidelines: Some institutions explicitly permit or prohibit using thesis questions for dissertations. Consult your program handbook or advisor for clear guidance. Supervisor approval: Your dissertation advisor plays a crucial role in shaping your research. Discuss your research goals and the potential of adapting your thesis question with them. Novelty and contribution: Ensure that the refined or adapted question retains originality and offers a substantial contribution to your field.

Conclusion

While it is generally not recommended to use the exact same research question for both a thesis and a dissertation, carefully refining or adapting the question with proper guidance and a focus on originality and contribution can be a successful strategy. Remember, your dissertation should represent a significant step forward in your research journey, showcasing your intellectual growth and independent research skills.