Einstein and Tesla: Their Complex Relationship and the Controversial Claims

Albert Einstein and Nikola Tesla, two of the most notable figures in the history of science, often come up in discussions about the greatest minds of their time. However, despite being contemporaries and sharing some common traits, their relationship was not as friendly as one might assume.

The Link Between Einstein and Tesla

Both Einstein and Tesla were well-known for their eccentric personalities, outspoken nature, and strong dedication to their work. Yet, their paths diverged significantly in terms of their focus and approach to science. Tesla was deeply involved in practical applications and the development of new technologies, especially in the field of alternating current (AC) power systems. On the other hand, Einstein’s expertise lay in the theoretical underpinnings of physics, particularly with his groundbreaking work on relativity.

Maxwell's Equations and Their Background

Both scientists were familiar with Maxwell's equations, which describe the behavior of electric and magnetic fields. For Einstein, these equations were the foundation of his theories. However, for Tesla, the equations were a starting point rather than the end goal. While Tesla delved into the practical implications of these principles, Einstein pursued deeper theoretical insights.

Einstein's Quirky Response

A memorable exchange between the two occurs when Einstein was asked how he felt about being the smartest man alive. His response, "I don't know, you'll have to ask Nikola Tesla," is often cited as evidence of a mutual respect. However, this exchange should be taken with a grain of salt. It is more likely a playful remark rather than a serious acknowledgment of Tesla's intelligence.

The Rivalry Between Tesla and Einstein

Contrary to popular belief, the relationship between Einstein and Tesla was not entirely cordial. Tesla, in particular, did not hold back in criticizing Einstein's theories, often publicly denouncing them. In one instance, Tesla said, "Einstein’s theories are nothing more than magnified mathematical garb which fascinates, dazzles, and makes people blind." He further stated, "The Relativity Theory is 'a beggar wrapped in purple whom ignorant people take for a king.'" These comments reflect Tesla's skeptical stance towards some of Einstein's theories, such as the theory of relativity.

Public Criticism and Disagreements

Tesla also publicly contested Einstein's theories on light, claiming to have detected particles from the sun that moved at speeds exceeding the speed of light. He termed these particles "Tesla waves." This public disagreement with Einstein was not an isolated incident but part of a broader battle for intellectual supremacy. Despite these disagreements, Einstein remained confident in his theories and let his work speak for itself.

The Final Tact: A Tinge of Sarcasm

On the occasion of Tesla's 75th birthday in 1931, he was featured on the cover of Time Magazine. The magazine asked Einstein for his thoughts on Tesla, and his response was telling. Einstein wrote, "Nikola Tesla is 'an imminent pioneer in the realm of high frequency current. I congratulate you on your great successes of your life’s work.'" While this may have been a genuine congratulatory message, it also carried a hint of sarcasm.

These exchanges highlight the complex relationship between Einstein and Tesla. While they shared a mutual respect for each other's scientific contributions, there were also moments of disagreement and public criticism. Both scientists were brilliant in their own right, and their contrasting approaches to science and their relationship provide an interesting lens through which to view the history of 20th-century physics.